Same-sex marriage verdict by the Supreme Court
Share on WhatsAppMore current affairs
GS 2
The Supreme Court ruled by a 3-2 majority that there is no legal recognition for same-sex marriages; key points of the five-judge bench ruling and the Mains perspective.
Key facts for Prelims
- No legal recognition of same-sex marriages.
- No constitutional or fundamental right to civil unions.
- The Centre's committee, headed by the cabinet secretary, will examine the concerns of same-sex couples.
- No right for queer couples to jointly adopt.
Same-sex marriage verdict highlights: The Supreme Court on Tuesday ruled that there cannot be legal recognition for same-sex marriages, doing so by a 3-2 majority.
Key points from the Supreme Court's five-judge bench ruling
- No legal recognition of same-sex marriages.
- No constitutional or fundamental right to civil unions.
- The Centre's high-powered committee will examine the concerns of same-sex couples.
- No right for queer couples to jointly adopt.
The Centre had opposed the pleas, arguing that the legislative policy of India has consciously validated a union only between a biological man and a biological woman. On May 3, the Centre told the top court it would constitute a committee headed by the cabinet secretary to examine administrative steps that could be taken to address "genuine concerns" of same-sex couples without going into the issue of legalising their marriage.
Three judges of the five-judge Constitution bench disagreed with the Chief Justice of India on adoption rights for LGBTQIA people, but agreed that the Special Marriage Act, 1956 (SMA) cannot be interpreted in such a manner as to enable marriage between queer persons.
Queerness is not "urban", says CJI
Queerness is not "urban" or "elite", and persons of any geographical location, background or caste may be queer, Chief Justice of India D Y Chandrachud said on Tuesday. He disagreed with the Centre's contention that the petitions seeking legal validation of same-sex marriage reflected an "urban elitist" view.
The CJI said that to imagine queer persons exist only in urban and affluent spaces is to erase them, even as they exist in other parts of the country, and that it would also be a mistake to conflate the "urban" with the "elite".
The Supreme Court has upheld the principle of parliamentary supremacy. It is not up to the courts to decide who gets married under what law. This is not a question of decriminalisation, as in the case of Section 377; it is about recognition of marriage.
Mains perspective
- Study the earlier judgement of the Supreme Court on Section 377 (decriminalisation).
- Study the approach of the international community towards LGBTQIA persons.

